Directed by: Jamie Babbit and Stefan Schwartz|
Distributed by: Amazon MGM Studios
Written by Livvy O’Brien
75/100
I love a good period drama, and “My Lady Jane” definitely delivers, but not in the way you’d expect it to. In a time where so many shows are battling for critical acclaim, this series boldly goes in the opposite direction—and it’s so much better for it.
Set in a fantasy reimagining of Tudor England, “My Lady Jane” follows the spirited Jane Grey as she is unwillingly thrust into a politically arranged marriage with the charming yet rebellious Lord Guilford Dudley. Their union sparks a whirlwind of emotions, secrets, and chaos—particularly when Jane unexpectedly becomes the Queen of England. Amid assassination attempts and courtly intrigue, Jane and Guilford must navigate the tumultuous challenges of their new roles, all while trying to make their marriage work.
I’ve always had a special place in my heart for history, particularly the Tudor period, and this show hit all the right notes for me. I’ve long felt sympathy for Lady Jane Grey’s tragic fate, so I was thrilled to see a series that finally gives her a lighthearted, if wildly inaccurate, spotlight. It’s a refreshing change from the grim history that so often defines her story as the Nine-Days’ Queen.
One of the show’s biggest strengths is its self-awareness. At times, the dialogue borders on cringey, but it does so with confidence, fully embracing its quirkiness. What I love is that the show knows exactly what it is—it’s here to entertain, lean into the fun, and not take itself too seriously. It revels in its playful take on history and romance, inviting viewers to enjoy the absurdity without hesitation. I mean, half the characters literally turn into animals! That’s used as a clever metaphor for the persecution of Protestants, fueled by Mary I’s deep-seated hatred for them. Of course, this hatred can be traced back to Henry VIII and his infamous mistreatment of his wives. We all know the rhyme: divorced, beheaded and died. Divorced, beheaded, survived. So grim.
But let’s talk about the chemistry. Jane and Guilford? To die for. Their relationship embodies every romance trope under the sun, and it works beautifully. From love—or more accurately, lust—at first sight, to an arranged marriage, enemies to lovers, and the ultimate star-crossed romance, they have it all. Every moment they share is charged with humour, wit, and genuine affection, making their relationship one of the show’s highlights. Whenever they’re on screen, I’m locked in.
This show features some of the most stunning costumes I’ve ever seen. Even if you’re not watching for the plot, the magnificently elaborate and historically inaccurate gowns are reason enough to tune in. The dresses are colourful, regal, and intricately designed, with a modern twist on the classic Tudor silhouette. The costumes perfectly embody each character’s personality and development, adding depth to the story. I also love that the show doesn’t shy away from the more absurd fashion trends of the time, especially with the men. In so many Tudor series, male clothing is watered down and simplified, but in “My Lady Jane,” the men are decked out in just as much colour and extravagance as the women, with plenty of jewels to match.
The biggest disappointment of “My Lady Jane” is that, much like the real Lady Jane Grey, the series was cut short before it had the chance to reach its full potential. Despite being set up for a second season, it wasn’t renewed. While the show doesn’t end on a major cliffhanger, it leaves several storylines open, offering plenty of room for further exploration. Sadly, it met the same fate as many other promising series, and won’t get a renewal. It’s a real shame because television needs more shows like this—ones that embrace fun for fun’s sake. The show took a risk, and it paid off wonderfully.
Amongst all of the heavy dramas, “My Lady Jane” is a breath of fresh air. It’s not afraid to lean into the absurd while still being emotionally charged, and that’s exactly why it’ll be missed.
“My Lady Jane” Trailer
You can follow Livvy O’Brien on Letterboxd.