Game of Thrones Retrospective: Kissed by Fire (Season Three, Episode Five)

Directed by: Alex Graves
Distributed by: HBO

Written by Anna Harrison

80/100

Overview

In these retrospectives, I will be looking back on “Game of Thrones” through my viewpoint as a fanatical fan of George R. R. Martin’s original book series, “A Song of Ice and Fire.” Mostly, I suspect this will be an exercise in venting my frustration about the adaptation of the books and pointing out where things went wrong in my mind—and I have a lot to work out.

For ease of reference, the show “Game of Thrones” can be abbreviated as “GOT” or “Thrones,” and the books in “A Song of Ice and Fire” can be abbreviated as “ASOIAF.” 

The books in the series are “A Game of Thrones,” “A Clash of Kings,” “A Storm of Swords,” “A Feast for Crows,” “A Dance With Dragons,” and the as-yet unpublished “The Winds of Winter” and “A Dream of Spring.” These can be abbreviated as “AGOT,” “ACOK,” “ASOS,” “AFFC,” “ADWD,” “TWOW,” and “ADOS.” 

Chapters within the book will be referred to by their point-of-view character and a Roman numeral indicating what chapter within the POV it is (ex., Catelyn I, Jaime II, Arya III, and so on), as Martin does not number his chapters nor name them besides indicating whose POV we are about to enter.

There are not many book series in the world where its readers have favorite chapters. Favorite characters, favorite arcs, favorite events, sure, but usually a favorite chapter is a bit too specific. “A Song of Ice and Fire,” however, is the kind of work where many fans do have a favorite chapter, owing to the density of George R. R. Martin’s writing and the delicacy of his character work. Just scour the internet and you will find an amazing number of blog posts and podcasts analyzing the books one chapter at a time, with pages upon pages or hours upon hours or analysis. (Of course, when you have no new material to work with for fifteen years, this is what you will be driven to.)

For me, the question of my favorite “ASOIAF” chapter is easy: it’s Jaime’s V, “A Storm of Swords.” Jaime V marks not only an emotional turning point for Jaime (Nikolaj Coster-Waldau) as he unburdens himself of the sins of his past to Brienne (Gwendoline Christie) in an increasingly-common moment of vulnerability, but a political one as well, as he attempts to play games with Roose Bolton (Michael McElhatton) and doesn’t realize that Roose is already ten steps ahead of him. 

“Kissed by Fire” only adapts the first half of this chapter, punting the latter portion to next episode, though if we’re being honest, it is that first half that makes the chapter really sing and thus vaults “Kissed by Fire” to amongst the top episodes of season three. 

Jaime can be an immensely frustrating character. He is arrogant, violent, and prone to pushing innocent children out of windows, but his inner thoughts are rich and beautiful. He avoids thinking about anything difficult, and often he will contradict himself when he talks, thinking one thing and saying another. The scene between him and Brienne in Harrenhal’s bathhouse marks the first time he has been utterly honest with both her and himself, and reorients nearly everything reader, viewer, and Brienne thought we/they knew. 

As Brienne washes off the stink of the road in Harrenhal’s bathhouse, she finds herself joined by Jaime, who hops into her occupied tub instead of using one of the other available ones. Even maimed as he is, he can’t resist the opportunity to poke at Brienne and make her feel uncomfortable, and there is some lovely physical acting from Christie here as she shrinks back into herself. 

Previously, Jaime’s slaying of Aerys Targaryen, the Mad King, was framed as cowardly: he was a Kingsguard, sworn to protect the royal family, and only stabbed Aerys in the back once it was clear that Daddy Tywin (Charles Dance) was there to save the day. In doing so, he forsook his vows to the Kingsugard and became, if not a pariah, then at least a stain upon the Kingsguard’s legacy. Here, stripped naked, robbed of his sword hand—“The hand that made me Kingslayer. The goat had robbed him of his glory and his shame, both at once. Leaving what? Who am I now?” (Jaime V, “ASOS”)—Jaime can finally reveal the truth: that Aerys intended to burn all of King’s Landing, and Jaime “soiled” his white cloak by preventing mass murder. 

I give this scene the highest praise I can offer: it’s just as good as it is in the book, and if the scene in the book is amongst one of my favorites in the entire series, that is a very big compliment indeed. Bryan Cogman served as writer for this episode, which comes as no surprise as he also wrote season two’s excellent “What Is Dead May Never Die” and would go on to write the only semi-acceptable episode in season eight, “A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms.” (He also was David Benioff and D. B. Weiss’s lore-keeper early on in the show, which perhaps exemplifies a stronger care for the material than his bosses had.) Even though Cogman cuts out large chunks of Jaime’s monologue from the books—we have no mention of Jon Connington, Rickard and Brandon Stark, Elia Martell, or a whole host of others mentioned—it works; in fact, keeping the focus so slim and narrow helps Coster-Waldau sell it. Jaime’s sprawling, fever-addled pages of words in the book work wonderfully on page, but would feel unwieldy on screen. The only line I lament the excision of is Jaime demanding of Brienne, “‘Has my tale turned you speechless? Come, curse me or kiss me or call me a liar. Something’” (Jaime V, “ASOS”). 

Cogman is helped, of course, by Coster-Waldau and Christie’s powerhouse performances. Coster-Waldau gets the showier stuff as he growls out, “By what right does the wolf judge the lion?” and lets out years of pent-up emotion, but Christie matches him perfectly, even though Brienne says little; we can see her opinion of Jaime shifting in real time, from fear to contempt to disbelief to, finally, sympathy. It can all be summed up in this note I jotted down while watching the episode: “this is a perfect scene idk what to say.” 

Another show might have put this momentous reveal at the end of the episode, but season three of “Game of Thrones” simply has too much to do, and there are at least two more momentous happenings in this episode that come before the Harrenhal bathtime confession.

“Kissed by Fire,” as a title, could refer to Jaime’s confession, obsessed as Aerys was with wildfire. Or it could apply to the trial by combat between Beric Dondarrion (Richard Dormer) and Sandor Clegane (Rory McCann), where Beric’s flaming sword—courtesy of Thoros of Myr (Paul Kaye)—brings back a boatload of trauma for the Hound. Still, that doesn’t stop him from killing Beric in an awkward fight scene with about ten too many cuts. 

The fight, however, is not the main draw of this opening scene: it’s what comes after. After Beric falls, Arya (Maisie Williams) leaps for the Hound, held back only by Gendry (Joe Dempsie) as she hisses and spits for him to die. Williams is at her best when Arya is allowed to show her personality, including all of her pent-up rage and anger, and she is excellent here (and I’m already dreading the flat, cold assassin they will turn her into). And then, from offscreen comes a familiar voice as Ramin Djawadi’s eerie Lord of Light theme plays: Beric Dondarrion, alive and well. 

But while Beric returns to life, in the North, Robb (Richard Madden) must mete out death. Rickard Karstark (John Stahl) has killed the two defenseless and young Lannister cousins Edmure (Tobias Menzies) had taken hostage, despite explicit orders not to, and thus Robb—as he learned from his father—must pass the sentence and swing the sword. The alliances holding the North together keep unraveling, with Robb at the center desperately trying to keep it all together and failing miserably, despite his best intentions. 

On a sour note, Catelyn (Michelle Fairley) fades into the background this episode, despite, of course, her being the books’ point of view on Robb and his entire campaign. In the show’s efforts to boost our opinion of Robb before killing him, they have pulled focus from Cat. Not surprising, and yet still disappointing. 

The show also—perhaps by virtue of aging Robb up—paints our King in the North as more self-assured than he is in “ASOIAF.” Show-Robb rarely wavers, and so we are robbed (ha) of this heartbreaking quote:

“Gods be good, why would any man ever want to be king? When everyone was shouting King in the North, King in the North, I told myself… swore to myself… that I would be a good king, as honorable as Father, strong, just, loyal to my friends and brave when I faced my enemies… now I can’t even tell one from the other. How did it all get so confused? Lord Rickard’s fought at my side in half a dozen battles. His sons died for me in the Whispering Wood. Tion Frey and Willem Lannister were my enemies. Yet now I have to kill my dead friends’ father for their sakes.” He looked at them all. “Will the Lannisters thank me for Lord Rickard’s head? Will the Freys?”

Catelyn III, A Storm of Swords

But, either way, justice is dispatched. In a mirror scene to Theon (Alfie Allen) last season, Robb removes Rickard Karstark’s head amongst the rain and as the score—the same motif for both of them—pounds and swells and digs his own grave even deeper in the process, just as Theon did with Rodrik Cassel (Ron Donachie). 

(And all of this before Jaime’s bath!)

As Rickard loses his head, we once again focus on the flames and use them to transition back to the Brotherhood Without Banners, where Arya asks Thoros, “Could you bring back a man without a head?” She refers not to Rickard, of course, but her father. Again, Arya and Williams are at their best when she is allowed to show emotion, especially when she lets the tough girl mask slip and shows that she is still just a child mourning the loss of her family. Again, however, the scene cuts a piece of dialogue from the books that would have enhanced the angst at least threefold, as Beric discusses the toll that his resurrections on him:

“That’s thrice I have died at the hands of House Clegane. You would think that I might have learned…”

It was a jest, Arya knew, but Thoros did not laugh. He put a hand on Lord Beric’s shoulder. “Best not to dwell on it.”

“Can I dwell on what I scarce remember? I held a castle on the Marches once, and there was a woman I was pledged to marry, but I could not find that castle today, nor tell you the color of that woman’s hair. Who knighted me, old friend? What were my favorite foods? It all fades. Sometimes I think I was born on the bloody grass in that grove of ash, with the taste of fire in my mouth and a hole in my chest. Are you my mother, Thoros?”

Arya VII, A Storm of Swords

That I am only mildly bitching about the exclusion of these bits of dialogue speaks to how excellent these scenes really are; they convey the emotion they ought to, even if they leave out some of Martin’s most stirring and tragic lines.

Even though death abounds in this episode, there is love and marriage, too (and no, I’m not referring to Jaime and Brienne in the bathhouse… although…). The original meaning of “Kissed by Fire,” of course, refers to the red hair of Ygritte (Rose Leslie), whose flirtation with Jon Snow (Kit Harington) finally is consummated. Their romance in the show, despite Harington and Leslie following suit in real life, has by and large felt unconvincing, though Ygritte does at least get Jon to show sparks of personality every so often. 

However, whilst book-Ygritte drives lots of juicy inner conflict with book-Jon, show-Jon is so flattened that she simply bounces off of him; there is nothing for her to push against. His worldview does not change because of her in the show, not really—or maybe it does, and Harington is not a strong enough actor to sell it. (Imagine, if you will, Harington delivering Jaime’s showstopper of a monologue from this episode. The horror.) He is and always remains honor-bound and nothing much more; though book-Jon will lie and stoop to some horrific lows to take what he views as the right course of action, show-Jon tends to favor the type of honor that Barristan Selmy (Ian McElhinney) describes this episode: “A man of honor keeps his vows, even if he’s serving a drunk or lunatic.” 

But, as we have seen this very episode… does a true man of honor keep those vows? Jaime’s feverish confession undercuts Barristan’s more straightforward interpretation. Is it honor to follow the king if he asks you to kill innocents? Is it honor to stand silently as Aerys Targaryen and later Robert Baratheon (Mark Addy) abused their respective wives? Is it more honorable to stab your king in the back? Or should Jaime have turned Aerys to face him as he cut the Mad King down?

Jaime, in “A Feast For Crows,” will have two horses named Glory and Honor, both named by his squire. When Brynden Tully (Clive Russell) asks him, “‘Do you even know what honor is?’” Jaime will think to himself, “A horse” (Jaime VI, “AFFC”). (I am inclined to believe this is a reference to Falstaff in “Henry IV Part One” on the battlefield: “What is honor? A word. What is in that word ‘honor’? What is that ‘honor’? Air.”) He has seen what doing what, to his mind, was the honorable thing will get you—scorn and hatred—and has turned his back on it. Barristan still seeks it. Robb will follow it to his death. 

Eventually, the show will plant itself firmly on the side of “honor is, by and large, pretty stupid and does nothing but ruin your life and/or get you killed.” But for now, “Kissed by Fire” has weightier stuff on its mind, more closely resembling Martin’s work. 

Except Jon. Never Jon.

Stray Observations:

  • I lied—the answer to my favorite chapter is actually not easy. Jaime V in “ASOS” is certainly up there, but so is Jaime VI and Sansa VII, and so is Theon’s chapter titled “A Ghost in Winterfell” in “A Dance With Dragons,” or Jon XIII in the same book, or Brienne VII in “A Feast for Crows”… you get the point. But it’s still probably Jaime V. 
  • We finally meet poor Shireen Baratheon (Kerry Ingram) in this episode, singing a song that, in the books, belongs to the prophetic and very creepy fool Patchface. After behaving poorly for the last few episodes, it’s nice to give Stannis (Stephen Dillane) a humanizing moment. It’s a wonder that the girl is as sweet as she is, considering that her mother, Selyse (Tara Fitzgerald), keeps her miscarried fetuses pickled in jars… which is one of those show-only inventions that is so outlandish and bizarre that I had completely blocked it out until rewatching this episode. It feels quite problematic in ways that I am unable to articulate right now. Woman goes crazy because she can’t have children. Or some such.
  • On the other hand, Shireen teaching Davos (Liam Cunningham) to read is also a show invention and is just wonderful.
  • The show is mean and clever with Robb’s scenes in this episode: his first—the beheading of Lord Karstark—highlights the fraying alliances amongst the North, and yet his last scene in the episode is almost optimistic as he proposes to take Casterly Rock. For those who don’t know what’s coming, it seems like a foregone conclusion that this season will end with a battle at Casterly Rock, and while lives may be lost, it will be epic. Hope springs eternal.
  • Grey Wind spotted at Riverrun! I repeat, Grey Wind spotted at Riverrun!
  • You know who’s not spotted this episode? Pyp (Josef Altin). Pyp watch is not doing so well.
  • In the books, Jaime gets an erection in the bathhouse scene, and still people try to claim that he isn’t attracted to Brienne. Okay! Brienne also remembers Jaime “looking half a corpse and half a god” (Brienne II, “AFFC”), which could mean nothing.
  • Relatedly, Jon also just magically knows how to give oral sex in the books, which… yeah, the books are still, at the end of the day, written by a guy.
  • Beric, as described by Sansa (Sophie Turner) in the first book: “Beric Dondarrion was handsome enough, but he was awfully old, almost twenty-two” (Sansa III, “AGOT”). She’s hilarious.
  • Sansa, whose hair used to mirror Cersei’s in season one and early season two as she was close to the Lannisters—first by choice and then by force—now begins to copy Margaery’s (Natalie Dormer) hairstyle in a nice bit of visual storytelling that the books could not do.
  • Dean Charles-Chapman reappears as one of the Lannister hostages this episode. See you soon, buddy.
  • Gendry and Arya this episode—very touching. He holds her back from committing an act of violence that might break her permanently, and then when Gendry tells her of his intent to stay with the Brotherhood: “I can be your family,” she says. “You wouldn’t be my family. You’d be ‘m’lady.’” 
  • Less touching—Loras Tyrell (Finn Jones) acting like Renly Baratheon (Gethin Anthony) never existed and jumping into bed with (unwittingly) one of Littlefinger’s (Aidan Gillen) spies. The show has had a bit of a… problem… in its handling of its gay characters. As with Brienne’s changed line (link s3e4) last episode, Loras’s reaction to Renly’s death is there in the text to draw upon, but the show falls back on the promiscuous gay man trope instead. Consider what Loras says in the books after Renly’s death: “When the sun has set, no candle can replace it” (Tyrion II, “ASOS”) and, “I will defend King Tommen with all my strength, I swear it. I will give my life for his if need be. But I will never betray Renly, by word or deed. He was the king that should have been. He was the best of them” (Jaime VIII, “ASOS”). Why go the extra mile to fall into lazy stereotypes when a much more interesting interpretation is right there? Why make Loras an idiot who tells family secrets to prostitutes? Unless…
  • The show ends on a quiet scene that nonetheless chilled me to the bone and broke my heart simultaneously. Tywin (Charles Dance) has gathered Tyrion (Peter Dinklage) and Cersei (Lena Headey) to inform them of their impending marriages: Tyrion to Sansa and Cersei to Loras. Both are horrified, and all three performers are—unsurprisingly—tremendous. Headey in particular as she pleads, “Father, don’t make me do it again, please,” is phenomenal. We even get a mention of Tysha, Tyrion’s long-lost wife, as Tywin inflicts pain on his children in order to control them. The episode ends with the Lannister siblings sitting in misery as an ironwrought lion looms over them in a painful bit of symbolism that reminds me of how good the show can be at times.
  • While marrying off Cersei in such fashion is, of course, horrific, and Tywin deserves everything coming to him, it is very funny to imagine her with any of the suitors proposed in the book: Willas Tyrell, Quentyn Martell, Horas or Hobber Redwyne (aka Horror and Slobber, Balon Greyjoy (Patrick Malahide), or, in my favorite pair to picture, Oberyn Martell (Pedro Pascal).

Episode Ranking:

“Game of Thrones” Season Three Trailer

You can follow more of Anna’s work on Letterboxd, Twitter. or her website.

Leave a Reply